
Do we really want self-rule?In the absence of the willingness to self-govern, or to have a conversation about how to be more effective at the little self-governing we actually do, is it fair to look at failing American states and cities as anomalous? Is it reasonable to suppose that they are, at bottom, that much different than Haiti, or Zimbabwe, Argentina or Venezuela? If Democracy is just used as an excuse to use an ignorant, disengaged populace as a path to power, isn’t the inevitable default to a kleptocracy? Were America’s founders wrong, in the end, in misjudging the willingness of enough people to engage in governance to make the American experiment work? If we abandon our responsibility to be informed and engaged enough to monitor and direct those we elect to public office, is a prosperous life under free-market capitalism sustainable? In other words, is the Chicago model of token democracy the default, the natural mode of a society too preoccupied individually to care that they are electing people whose sole incentive is to loot the government and divert the public purse to themselves and their necessary allies (e.g., unions)? Are Ayn Rand’s looters (of the treasury and the productive sector) not necessarily a spiral towards collapse, but a form of stagnation that is sustainable as long as you have enough employers who won’t go John Galt and either drop out or limit their own productivity? After all, Chicago can hollow out its public services with patronage, extravagant contracts, exuberant pensions and sell-offs of public assets. In return, the citizens of that fair city get fifty years of one-party rule and a minimum of actual public service: Poor schools, transport, education and safety – but not poor enough to create demand for change. Just wondering, because it appears that while American constitutional principles are scalable to any population size, the 1787 system designed for their implementation is not. It’s too easy, in a massive population, for the weak and corrupt to hide from citizen scrutiny. It’s too easy for the corrupt to manipulate parts of a large system to continue reading















.jpg)

